Energy Monopoly States vs. Energy Choice States

Andre Velez • October 5, 2023

Customers In Monopoly States See Prices Rise 40%; Electric Rates In Choice States Rose Only 10%

The Retail Energy Supply Association (RESA) has released its 2022 data report, using the latest information from the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA).


Here's the key takeaway: Since 2008, the average electricity prices for customers in places where they have choices (competitive states/jurisdictions) have gone up by about 10.6%. But in areas where there's only one utility company (monopoly states), prices have shot up much more, by about 40.3%. This means people in monopoly states could have saved more than $628 billion if their prices had risen like those in places with competition since 2008.


Breaking it down by customer type, these potential savings in monopoly states would have been approximately $212.9 billion for regular households, $260.4 billion for businesses, and $155.0 billion for industries. Meanwhile, in the 14 competitive states/jurisdictions, they managed to save about $430 billion during this time compared to the monopoly states. These numbers emphasize how much competitive power markets can save people on their electricity bills.


In 2022, over 13.2 million households in competitive states got their electricity from competitive retail suppliers, which is about 45.0% of the households in those states that can choose their electricity provider.



Tracy McCormick, the executive director of RESA, noted, "The data makes it clear: when people have options, they make smart choices, recognizing the benefits of competitive markets." RESA's president, Gretchen Fuhr, added, "This data strongly emphasizes the importance of giving consumers the freedom to choose their electricity providers. It's not just about saving money; it's also about encouraging innovation and sustainable energy solutions in the industry."


have questions?

Contact us or get a free energy analysis today

GET A FREE ENERGY ANALYSIS
By Merrill Mangalasseril • November 2, 2026
Winter 2026–2027 Energy Renewals: What We've Learned and What's Changing Why timing, capacity costs, and supplier relationships matter more than ever this renewal season. As we enter November, Ananta Energy Source is preparing to help clients navigate one of our busiest renewal periods of the year.  We have more than 110 commercial accounts approaching year-end renewals, with another 40+ accounts scheduled for January and February 2027. But this isn't simply about renewing contracts. It's about applying what we've learned from previous winters, changing supplier requirements, and evolving electricity markets to make better purchasing decisions for our clients.
By Merrill Mangalasseril • October 13, 2026
Nearly 20 years in energy procurement, 15 years of Ananta Energy Source, and somehow, every hospitality conference still teaches me something new. After another incredible experience at The Lodging Conference, here are six takeaways that stuck with me.
By Merrill Mangalasseril • February 18, 2026
Capacity Isn’t Just Another Line Item — It’s the Hidden Risk Most Energy Contracts Don’t Explain 
By Merrill Mangalasseril • November 17, 2025
Energy Market Update: What Happened, What’s Next, and How We Navigate the Next 30 Days
By Merrill Mangalasseril • November 13, 2025
2025 Ohio Utility Price-To-Compare (PTC)
By Merrill Mangalasseril • November 11, 2025
2025 Energy Strategy: What I’d Do If This Were My Hotel
By Merrill Mangalasseril • October 21, 2025
Fighting Back Against Ohio’s Capacity Rate Hikes: How Hotel Owners Can Leverage Ananta’s Proven Approach
By Merrill Mangalasseril • September 29, 2025
Transparency, Trust, and Community: What Sets Us Apart in Energy Procurement
By Merrill Mangalasseril • May 2, 2025
ComEd Time-of-Day Pricing vs. Supplier Index Day-Ahead Rates: A Hotel Owner’s Guide
By Merrill Mangalasseril • March 10, 2025
Natural Gas Market Summary – March 10, 2025